Guilty Plea to Assaulting Cooperator Is In Doubt Four Years Later In Empty SDNY Courthouse, In-Person Habeus Corpus Hearing In A Plexiglass Box
Robert Gist emerged from the Special Housing Unit of the MDC to described being railroaded into pleading guilty to something he has he didn't do. It should be decided by Christmas
By Matthew Russell Lee, Exclusive PodPatreon
BBC - Guardian UK - Honduras - ESPN
SDNY COURTHOUSE, Dec 8 – Robert Gist came to plead guilty on February 15, 2018 to selling marijuana in The Bronx and to assaulting Cicero Williams while in prison a year before.
At the change of plea proceeding his lawyer Aaron Goldsmith began by apologizing for not having changed his clothes and instead being dressed casually, saying that the plea deal had come together very quickly.
It should have been apparent that something was wrong.
That day, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York Judge Gregory H. Woods accepted the plea.
He asked Robert Gist, "please tell me what it is that you did that makes you believe that you are guilty of these offenses."
Robert Gist said, "on February 4, 2017, I assaulted Cicero Williams while both of us were incarcerated at MCC. At the time, I knew it was wrong to assault him. I also believed that he was cooperating with the government."
Now on December 8, 2020, in a SDNY courthouse nearly emptied amid the COVID-19 pandemic, Robert Gist appeared before Judge Woods again, from inside a plexiglass box.
Inner City Press was the only one in the courtroom gallery, so empty that when pulling out a pen to take notes brought out a quarter to fall on the bench, the noise distracted the court reporter.
This was an evidentiary hearing in a habeus corpus proceeding brought by Robert Gist. There were only two witnesses: him and then, for the government, Aaron Goldsmith.
To get this far, Gist had been required to waive his attorney client privilege. Gist recounted being involved of the plea deal he agreed to only shortly before the proceeding, and having told Goldsmith he has assault Williams because Williams had called him a "rat," not the other way around.
He said Goldsmith told him he would probably get a sentence of 24 to 36 months, and to take the deal before he, Goldsmith, had to fly to Los Angeles for a week.
Judge Woods didn't know any of this, back then. He accepted the plea, and months later sentenced Robert Gist to 77 months. Gist on December 8 recounted how he had been confused and shocked.
Goldsmith, who testified by Skype, argued that he had made all the required disclosures to Gist.
He acknowledged he had been on his way to Los Angeles but said he would have taken his laptop there and continued to work on the case if Gist had not pled guilty.
While insisting that Gist never told him to file a notice of appeal, he added that if he had, he would have told Gist that he was quitting, as there was not basis to appeal, Gist's deal also waive appellate rights for any sentence below 96 months.
A key issue at the hearing, not yet decided by Judge Woods, was whether the Assistant US Attorney had handed Goldsmith a piece of paper with what Gist was supposed to say in his allocution (that he "believed that [Cicero Williams] was cooperating with the government"), or whether Goldsmith had written the word and showed them to the prosecutor to make sure they were sufficient.
His original notes were somehow not in the supposedly complete file for the case.
After two and a half hours, Judge Woods asked the parties to submit briefs on whether he could consider written testimony from Gist's grandfather, given health issues, and said he would be awaiting any subpoena returns from the MCC.
Expect the habeus corpus petition be ruled on by Christmas. Inner City Press will continue to report on the case. It is Gist v. US, 19-cv-5095 (Woods)
***
Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.
Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA
Mail: Box 20047, Dag Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017